You don’t have to look too far to find blips and telltales in the economy that suggest this could be a rough holiday season. You may already have been seeing it in your art sales in recent months.
Consumer confidence is down. Spending is spotty. People are still spending money, but very selectively. If it wasn’t challenging enough already to be an artist, I think this is one of those times when it’s even harder.
You can’t give up, but you don’t necessarily need to throw as much at it as you might have in better times or when you were feeling a little more optimistic.
There are stories about one business that kept advertising during hard times and emerged ahead of its competition. Believe me, when I was selling advertising, I wore that one out. It was mostly anecdotal. If there were statistics and reliable sources to back it up, I don’t remember them.
But that was then. We’re in a different economy, a different political environment, and a different world of information distribution than ever before.
Artists Are Feeling Things
Many people get their news from social media—TikTok, Instagram—and bits and pieces from news sites. They’re getting sound bites and trying to make sense of it all. Much of what shapes their outlook comes down to how they feel.
I think artists have always been particularly sensitive to what’s going on around them. Art history is full of examples of artists responding to profound changes in society, sometimes before the rest of us recognize their significance.
Perhaps artists today are perceiving, not only in their pocketbooks but in their senses, that things are not like they used to be. We don’t know where things are going. I feel cautiously optimistic that better days are ahead, but getting there is neither quick nor guaranteed.
None of us knows what the future holds. We never did. So, I’m neither hunkering down nor going all in for now.
We’ve Been Here Before, Sort Of
A friend of mine was looking at how AI might let him replace his $2,300 annual email marketing bill with a $100-a-month AI service that also does dozens of other things to help him run his business.
While that’s great for him, it’s not so great for the people at the email marketing company whose livelihoods depend on its revenue.
It reminds me of when the internet wave came through and upended so many businesses in the mid-to-late 1990s, including mine.
I worked in trade shows and trade magazines. What had once been an industry’s monthly go-to resource quickly became less relevant as detailed facts and information became available almost instantly. The newsletter business and other traditional media felt the impact, too.
Something similar is likely going on now, only on a much broader scale. Even if AI isn’t disrupting your business model, it may be disrupting your potential customers' business models.
And that’s just one source of unease among many, which makes cautious optimism seem like the best approach. That’s because amidst the gloom and fear, people like futurist Peter Diamandis offer a more hopeful perspective, arguing that accelerating advances in technology are moving us toward an age of abundance and possibilities we can scarcely imagine today.
A Little Practical Minimalism
Maybe now is a time to consolidate a little bit and think about what you’re doing. Apply some practical minimalism to your art business.
Stop spending on things you don’t really need. This may not be the time to add expensive tools or premium services when you can get by with a free alternative or nothing at all. I’ve been doing that for the last year—just paring down and being selective about my tech stack and business expenses.
It’s surprising how many things we once considered essential turn out to be things we can do quite well without.
Don't be overly careful about eliminating things that genuinely contribute to your success or enrich your life as an artist. There’s a difference between being prudent and being miserly, and the distinction is worth making.
The idea is to use what you have better, not deprive yourself of what you need.
Consolidating Is Not Retreating
Much of what you can do to improve your prospects as an artist costs little or nothing.
You can get to know the people who already own your art a little better. You can renew acquaintances, make new friends, have interesting conversations, and find more ways to become involved with people who share your interests.
You can devote more time to making the kind of art you want to be known for. You can learn to tell better stories about yourself and your work. You might spend some time thinking about what you really want from your art business and whether you’re pursuing it in a way that suits you.
These are things worth doing in good times and bad, and their benefits tend to accumulate.
You don’t have to put your future on hold just because you’re uncertain about it.
Now What?
I’m not suggesting you close up shop and go off the grid. I am suggesting that now might be a time to be a little more prudent about where you put your money, time, and energy.
I’m also aware that this kind of advice, when followed by enough people, pulls even more money out of the economy. It becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy of sorts. I appreciate the irony, but I don’t have a better solution for you. But it’s also worth noting that for every action, there is a reaction. Even when things seem completely off-kilter, the pendulum eventually swings back to balance things.
What I do know is that there’s no shortage of worthwhile things you can do as an artist that aren’t dependent on the economy getting better.
When circumstances become more favorable, you’ll be glad you did them. And in the meantime, there’s every reason to enjoy doing them for their own sake.
Make art. Stay curious. Now more than ever, find new ways to keep in touch with people. Be judicious about what you spend, and generous with what you have to offer.
It’s always good to remember that you still get to decide what a good deal looks like in your life as an artist.
See you next week.
— Barney



